Researchers in Germany have observed a fundamental tradeoff in the behaviour of electrons: the more precisely their motion is pinned down in time, the more their quantum wave packets spread out in space. The result, reported in Nature Photonics, gives experimental substance to what the team calls a space-time limit for electron tracking.
The work comes from the Regensburg Center for Ultrafast Nanoscopy, or RUN, at the University of Regensburg, in collaboration with a group at the Max Planck Institute in Hamburg. The researchers used a purpose-built laser system and an ultrafast microscope to drive electrons from a sharp metal tip toward a silver surface across a gap of only a few atomic diameters.
The experiments operate on attosecond timescales. An attosecond is a billionth of a billionth of a second, and electrons can move roughly a thousand times faster than atoms in these settings. Watching them requires instruments far beyond conventional microscopy.
What the team saw was quantum tunneling. Rather than crossing the gap like tiny classical particles, the electrons behaved as waves that could pass through an energy barrier separating tip from surface. By varying the interval between two laser pulses, the researchers could track when the tunneling occurred.
Computer simulations reproduced the measurements and revealed that the electrons lagged behind the light field by about 500 attoseconds. The simulations also exposed the underlying tradeoff: tighter timing required more energy, and more energy made the electron wave packet spread further in space.
The finding is a piece of fundamental physics, but the researchers point to possible long-term applications. Concentrating a single electron into an extremely small region of space and time can produce a very high local peak current density, which might be used to influence chemical reactions. The team also suggests that electronics could one day operate far closer to the intrinsic speed of electron motion than today's CMOS technology. That possibility remains a distant goal, not a demonstrated device.
A limit beyond Heisenberg's familiar rule
Quantum mechanics places limits on what can be known about particles. The best-known example is Werner Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, which states that certain pairs of properties, such as position and momentum, cannot both be determined with unlimited precision. The restriction is built into the structure of the theory, not into the quality of laboratory instruments.
Position and time are different. The standard Heisenberg relation does not impose the same restriction on those two quantities, which is why researchers have long asked whether electrons could in principle be tracked with arbitrary accuracy in both space and time. The new experiments suggest that they cannot.
The reported space-time limit is distinct from the familiar position-momentum tradeoff. It concerns the spatial extent of an electron's wave packet and how precisely the timing of its motion can be defined. In the Regensburg measurements, improving time resolution came at the cost of spatial localisation.
The authors describe the result as an experimentally observed relationship that had previously been suspected rather than directly demonstrated. It does not overturn quantum mechanics; it reveals another consequence of the theory when electrons are probed at extreme scales.
The distinction matters because much of modern technology depends on moving and measuring electrons. If there is a fundamental boundary on how well both space and time can be controlled, engineers need to understand where it lies before designing devices that approach it.
Why watching electrons is harder than watching atoms
The Regensburg group already had experience resolving motion at the atomic scale. About a decade earlier, researchers there used ultrafast scanning tunnelling microscopy to follow the movement of a single molecule across both space and time for the first time. Electrons present a harder target.
At the distances involved in a tunnelling junction, electrons move roughly a thousand times faster than atoms or molecules. The relevant changes unfold in attoseconds, a unit so small that the comparison is hard to visualise. An atom is about ten million times smaller than a millimetre, and the ratio between an attosecond and a second is comparable to the ratio between one second and the age of the universe.
A conventional microscope cannot resolve such events. Even an ultrafast instrument must be designed so that its time resolution matches the motion it hopes to capture. That requirement drove the construction of a new laser system with much finer temporal control than earlier setups.
Electrons also do not behave like ordinary objects. Their motion follows quantum mechanics, so a measurement that reveals where an electron is likely to be can disturb how its wave-like properties are distributed. Observing a fast electron is therefore not simply a matter of taking a shorter exposure.
The team's approach was to combine spatial confinement at the tip with precise timing from laser pulses, then infer the electron's behaviour from the resulting electrical current. That combination brought them close to what they call the space-time limit.
Building a faster attosecond laser
To reach the required time resolution, the researchers built a new laser system capable of delivering pulses separated by precisely controlled intervals. The pulses were used to drive electrons out of an atomically sharp metal tip and toward a silver surface.
The gap between tip and sample was only a few atomic diameters wide. At that scale, the electric field of a light pulse can strongly influence the electrons in the tip, pulling them toward the surface within a very short window of time.
The experimental readout was an electrical current. By changing the delay between two laser pulses and observing how the current changed, the team could work out when the electrons responded. The method is analogous to a pump-probe experiment, in which one pulse initiates a process and a second interrogates it at a later moment.
The extremely short timescale means that the shape of the light pulse matters as much as its intensity. The researchers found that the laser field could not be described entirely as a classical wave or entirely as a stream of photons. The data showed characteristics of both descriptions, and that dual character was important for exploring electron behaviour near the space-time limit.
The laser work was carried out at RUN, which brings together researchers in physics and nanoscopy at Regensburg. The collaboration also included theorists in Hamburg, whose simulations were needed to interpret the measurements.
Tunneling from a metal tip to silver
In classical physics, an electron without enough energy cannot cross a barrier. In quantum mechanics, it can, because its wave-like nature gives it a nonzero probability of appearing on the other side. This phenomenon is known as quantum tunnelling, and it underlies devices such as the scanning tunnelling microscope.
In the Regensburg experiment, electrons tunnelled from the metal tip to the silver surface under the influence of the laser field. The distance was only a few atomic diameters, small enough that tunnelling could occur within an attosecond-scale window.
Simon Maier, the paper's lead author, has described the experiment in terms of varying the interval between the laser pulses and directly observing how the electrons respond. That description captures the basic logic: the timing of the response reveals the dynamics of the tunnelling process.
The team detected evidence of electron motion occurring on attosecond timescales, showing that the pulses could transfer electrons within extremely brief intervals. The measurement did not simply confirm that current flowed; it resolved when the transfer happened.
Katharina Glöckl, a doctoral student and co-author, has likened the measurement to a high-speed camera for electron wave packets, in that it shows the point in time at which tunnelling takes place. That analogy also hints at the limit the team encountered: a faster shutter comes with a cost in spatial sharpness.
The 500-attosecond delay
The experimental data alone did not reveal every detail of the process. To interpret them, researchers working with Angel Rubio at the Max Planck Institute in Hamburg ran sophisticated quantum simulations of electrons near the space-time limit.
The calculations closely reproduced the measurements. They also uncovered a detail that the raw current data could not express directly: the electrons did not respond instantaneously to the light field. Their motion lagged behind it by approximately 500 attoseconds.
A delay of half an attosecond is almost meaningless outside the world of ultrafast physics, but at this scale it is a measurable and informative quantity. It indicates that the electron dynamics have their own timescale, shaped by the quantum properties of the tunnelling process and by the way the light field interacts with the tip and surface.
The simulations also showed why a simple picture of the laser field was inadequate. Treating the light purely as a wave or purely as photons failed to capture the full behaviour. Both descriptions were needed to reproduce what the electrons did.
That finding connects the experiment to fundamental questions about light-matter interaction. At ordinary scales, physicists can often choose whichever description is more convenient. Near the space-time limit, the choice becomes consequential, and the theory must accommodate both aspects at once.
Wave packets and the space-time tradeoff
Quantum mechanics describes an electron not as a point but as a wave packet: a spread-out object whose shape indicates where the particle is likely to be found. The Regensburg team found that controlling when an electron moves changes how widely that packet extends in space.
Raffael Spachtholz, a co-author of the study, has explained the tradeoff in straightforward terms. Pinning down the electron's position in time more precisely requires more energy, and supplying that energy causes the wave packet to spread more spatially.
This is the central result of the paper. It is not a limitation of the laser or the microscope, but a relationship between the spatial and temporal properties of the electron's quantum state under the conditions of the experiment.
The team examined the connection by placing a single atom on the surface. That atom confined the electron wave packets to an extremely small region immediately before the laser pulses arrived, allowing the researchers to measure the relationship between spatial distribution and the timing of motion.
Importantly, the wave packets remained localised enough for microscopy with atomic spatial resolution and attosecond time resolution, even when the electrons received substantial energy from the laser pulses. The tradeoff therefore does not prevent high-resolution experiments; it defines the boundary within which they must operate.
Confining electrons with a single atom
The decision to place a single atom on the surface was a practical way to impose spatial confinement. The atom acted as a localised region where electrons could be held before the laser pulses triggered their movement.
That setup gave the researchers a controlled starting point. Without such confinement, the initial spatial distribution of the wave packets would have been less well defined, making it harder to relate spatial spread to timing precision.
The experiment therefore combined two forms of control: atomic-scale confinement from the surface atom, and attosecond-scale timing from the laser pulses. Bringing them together let the team observe the space-time relationship directly rather than inferring it from theory.
The result also demonstrates the maturity of ultrafast microscopy. Being able to position an atom, deliver a precisely timed light pulse and measure the resulting current in a single experiment is a demanding combination. The Regensburg group has spent years developing the techniques that made it possible.
The authors are careful about the scope of the achievement. They have measured a specific tradeoff in a specific experimental setting. They have not shown that all electron dynamics are governed by the same quantitative relationship, nor that every material system behaves identically.
Peak current density and chemical reactions
One potential application of the work lies in chemistry. Transferring a single electron to a molecule is the smallest possible transfer of electric charge. If that electron is compressed into an exceptionally small region of space and time, the resulting local current density becomes very large.
The researchers calculate that the peak current density can reach as much as 1 trillion amperes per square centimetre under such conditions. That figure describes an extremely local and brief event, not a current that could be sustained through a wire.
Jascha Repp has suggested that such wave packets could eventually be used to trigger chemical reactions and to observe, on the relevant length and time scales, how chemical bonds are broken or altered. The idea is to use a precisely timed electron as a tool for initiating and watching a reaction as it unfolds.
That ambition connects ultrafast microscopy with the broader goal of controlling matter at the atomic level. Chemists have long wanted to observe reactions in real time rather than inferring pathways from start and end products. Attosecond control over electrons could add a new dimension to that effort.
The current experiments do not demonstrate chemical control. They establish that electrons can be tracked and manipulated close to the space-time limit, which is a prerequisite for the proposed applications.
The long road to faster electronics
The most eye-catching implication of the research concerns the speed of electronics. Rupert Huber has said that the insights could eventually contribute to operating electronics and quantum information processing at the intrinsic speed limit of electron motion itself, hundreds of thousands of times faster than dominant CMOS technology.
That statement describes a long-term possibility, not a result achieved in the laboratory. Today's processors operate on timescales many orders of magnitude slower than attosecond electron dynamics. Bridging that gap would require new device concepts, new materials and new ways of controlling and reading out signals.
The relevance of the study is that it identifies the scale at which such devices would eventually operate, and demonstrates that electrons can be followed at that scale under controlled conditions. It also shows where the fundamental tradeoffs lie, which is useful information for anyone trying to design a machine that approaches them.
The Nobel Prize in Physics 2023, awarded for work on attosecond pulses and electron dynamics, reflects the broader importance of this timescale in modern physics. The Regensburg experiment sits within that tradition while adding a specific measurement of the space-time constraint.
For now, the practical consequences are likely to be gradual. Advances in ultrafast microscopy tend to feed first into fundamental research, then into specialised tools, and only much later into consumer technology.
Where the research sits today
The paper, titled "Tracking electrons at the space-time limit," was published in Nature Photonics, volume 20, in 2026. The DOI is 10.1038/s41566-026-01932-0. The lead author is Simon Maier, and the author list includes researchers from Regensburg and the Max Planck Institute in Hamburg.
The collaboration involves groups led by Jascha Repp, Rupert Huber, Franz Giessibl and Klaus Richter at RUN, together with Angel Rubio's team. That mix of experimental and theoretical expertise was needed both to perform the measurements and to interpret them.
The experiments answer a basic question about how precisely electrons can be followed in space and time. They also open several new ones. How does the tradeoff vary in different materials? Can it be used deliberately to shape electron wave packets? And can the techniques be extended to more complex structures than a tip and a silver surface?
The researchers expect to explore those questions in the coming years. For the moment, their result stands as a careful measurement of a fundamental limit, with applications that remain promising but distinctly futuristic.
What the finding means for quantum technology
The space-time limit is a reminder that quantum mechanics constrains not only what can be known about a particle but how precisely a process can be controlled. For quantum technology, where information is often encoded in the behaviour of individual particles, such constraints are engineering realities rather than philosophical points.
The same tradeoff that limits electron tracking could influence how future devices balance speed against spatial precision. A system designed to exploit extremely fast electron motion may have to accept a broader spatial distribution, and vice versa. Understanding that balance is part of designing any technology that operates near the fundamental scale.
The study also illustrates the value of combining experiment and simulation. The 500-attosecond delay and the dual wave-photon character of the laser interaction emerged from the theoretical work, not from a direct reading of the current trace. Without the simulations, the measurements would have been harder to interpret.
That interplay is likely to continue as ultrafast science pushes toward shorter timescales. Experiments will provide increasingly detailed data, while theory will be needed to explain what those data mean. The result is a clearer picture of how electrons behave at the boundary between the measurable and the possible.
Nexuswild welcomes factual corrections. Email contact@nexuswild.com with evidence and the article URL.
