A survey of plant-based foods sold in the United Kingdom has reported a result that sounds more alarming than it is: every one of the 212 products tested contained at least one mycotoxin, a naturally occurring compound produced by certain fungi. The finding, published in the journal Food Control, did not identify any product above European Union guideline levels. Rather, it described how widely low-level contaminants can appear across a fast-growing category of foods built from grains, legumes and seeds.

The work was led by researchers at the University of Parma in Italy, with contributors from Cranfield University in the United Kingdom. The team screened vegan and vegetarian meat alternatives and dairy substitutes, including burgers, sausages, meat-free chicken pieces, and oat, almond and soy drinks. They looked for 19 different mycotoxins and detected at least one in each sample, with many products containing several.

Mycotoxins are a familiar concern in conventional food safety. They can form in crops in the field or during storage, and regulators in many countries set maximum levels for the compounds most likely to reach consumers through cereals, nuts, spices and dried fruit. What is less settled is how to assess exposure from newer product categories that combine many plant ingredients in a single item. A burger analogue, for example, may draw on soy or pea protein, grain binders, oils, spices and flavourings, each with its own potential contamination profile.

The researchers say their results should be read as a mapping exercise rather than a warning to abandon plant-based diets. All measured concentrations stayed below the EU guidance values used as a benchmark, and the team noted that these foods are produced within a food system with high quality standards. At the same time, the authors argue that the absence of specific mycotoxin monitoring rules for many of these products, together with the possibility of repeated exposure across a whole diet, makes further work worthwhile.

The study arrives as plant-based foods move from niche shelves into mainstream retail. Researchers and regulators increasingly need evidence about what these products contain, not just how they are made or marketed. The Parma and Cranfield teams are continuing to work together on dietary exposure models intended to estimate how different eating patterns change the amount of these compounds a person encounters over time.

What the survey actually tested

The investigation centred on two broad groups of products. The first group, described in the paper as plant-based meat alternatives, included items designed to replace burgers, sausages and chicken pieces. The second group covered plant-based beverages, with oat, almond and soy milk among the drinks examined. Together, the two groups amounted to 212 items purchased from the UK market.

That sample size matters for interpretation. A survey of this kind is not a census of every product available, nor is it a test of a single brand. It is a snapshot of a selection of items commonly found on supermarket shelves at the time of collection. The researchers screened each item for 19 mycotoxins, a panel broad enough to capture several of the compound families that food-safety agencies monitor most closely in raw agricultural commodities.

Reporting that all 212 samples contained at least one compound does not mean all 212 samples contained the same compound. The paper notes that many products held multiple mycotoxins. That detail is important because risk assessment usually considers the specific toxins present, their concentrations and the foods that carry them, rather than treating all detections as equivalent.

The authors chose the UK market in part because of its retail structure and its food-quality controls. In their interpretation, the fact that every detection remained below EU guideline values says something about the manufacturing and ingredient controls applied to these products. It does not erase the detections themselves, but it frames them as evidence of widespread low-level presence rather than of unsafe food.

The journal reference lists Raquel Torrijos, Octavian Augustin Mihalache, Andrea Patriarca, Angel Medina and Chiara Dall'Asta as authors. The paper was published in Food Control, volume 183, under the title "Mycotoxin contamination in plant-based beverages and meat alternatives: A survey of the UK market."

Why grains and seeds can carry fungal toxins

Mycotoxins are chemical compounds produced by certain moulds. They are not living organisms, and their presence in a finished food does not mean that the food contains active mould growth. Contamination usually begins earlier, while a crop is growing in a field or while harvested grain, legumes or seeds are being stored.

The ingredients most often associated with plant-based manufacturing are also among those most vulnerable to this kind of contamination. Cereals, pulses, oilseeds and nuts can be exposed to fungi in soil, in the air or in storage facilities. Moisture, temperature and storage duration all influence whether moulds grow and whether they produce toxins under a given set of conditions.

That agricultural reality is why food-safety authorities treat mycotoxins as a supply-chain issue rather than a problem confined to a particular kind of meal. The European Food Safety Authority, for example, maintains scientific assessments of several mycotoxins and derives health-based guidance values that can inform risk management. The World Health Organization likewise describes mycotoxins as contaminants of food crops, with aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, fumonisins, trichothecenes and zearalenone among the compounds of greatest international concern.

For a manufacturer of meat alternatives or plant milks, the issue is compounded by ingredient complexity. A single formulation can draw on protein isolates, flours, starches, oils and seasonings from multiple suppliers and regions. Each input brings its own agricultural history. Once those inputs are blended, tracking the origin of a detected compound becomes more difficult than it would be in a single-ingredient commodity such as wheat flour or maize.

The Cranfield and Parma researchers therefore emphasise raw-material monitoring. Identifying and controlling contamination before ingredients are combined gives manufacturers a more direct way to manage risk than trying to correct a finished product. Their broader project, FunShield4Med, is funded through the European Union's Horizon Europe programme and is designed to improve forecasting of fungal spoilage and mycotoxin threats across food systems.

The finding: one or more toxins in every product

The headline result was uniform: every sample returned at least one positive detection from the 19-compound panel. Such a rate is unusual in consumer-facing reporting, where surveys often find a mixture of positives and non-detects. The authors present it as a reflection of how common these compounds are in the underlying ingredient pool, not as evidence of a manufacturing failure.

Multiple detections were common. That pattern is consistent with what food-safety researchers often observe in multi-ingredient products, where different raw materials can contribute different compounds. A grain-based binder and a spice blend, for instance, may carry distinct contamination profiles that survive processing into a finished item.

The study did not rank products by brand or publish a league table of better and worse choices. Its purpose was to describe the category as a whole and to generate data that can feed exposure assessments. That distinction matters for consumers who might otherwise read the finding as a reason to switch from one product to another within the same category.

The researchers also caution against conflating detection with danger. Whether a detected concentration is meaningful depends on the toxin, the amount present, the portion size and how often the food is eaten. All concentrations in this survey were below EU guideline levels, which are intended to keep dietary exposure within bounds considered acceptable by risk assessors.

At the same time, the team argues that the ubiquity of low-level detections is itself informative. If mycotoxins are present across nearly every item in a category, then the relevant question for public health shifts from "does this product contain a toxin?" to "how much of each toxin do people consume across their whole diet, and over what period?"

Concentrations and the EU guideline benchmark

European Union guideline levels for mycotoxins are set for specific compounds in specific foods. They are not a single universal threshold, and they are derived from toxicological evidence about the amount of a substance that can be consumed without appreciable health risk. In this survey, the researchers used those values as a reference point for the concentrations they measured.

Every product in the sample fell below the applicable benchmark. The authors interpreted this as evidence that the UK food industry maintains high standards for the ingredients and finished goods examined. It also means the study cannot be used to claim that the tested products are unsafe under current guidance.

Risk assessors nevertheless distinguish between compliance and zero exposure. A food can meet a legal or guideline limit and still contribute to a person's total intake, particularly when it is eaten frequently. EFSA's work on mycotoxins, for instance, often involves estimating dietary exposure across population groups and comparing those estimates with health-based guidance values such as tolerable daily intakes.

The Parma and Cranfield team make a similar point about cumulative exposure. Earlier research has suggested that regular consumption of small amounts of mycotoxins may contribute to a person's overall burden over time. That does not establish harm from any single product, but it does make the pattern of repeated consumption relevant to risk assessment.

The survey therefore provides concentration data that can be combined with food-consumption surveys. Once researchers know how much of each compound is present and how often people eat the relevant products, they can estimate intake for different dietary patterns. That is the next stage of the collaboration, and it is where the public-health value of the measurements is likely to emerge.

Which products were included in the scan

The 212 items covered a recognisable slice of a modern supermarket. Plant-based meat alternatives included products labelled as vegan burgers, vegetarian chicken-style pieces and vegan sausages. Plant-based beverages included oat, almond and soy milk. These are among the most widely distributed items in the category, and they rely heavily on grains, legumes and seeds.

The choice of beverages is significant because plant milks are often consumed daily, sometimes in large volumes and by people who avoid dairy for dietary, ethical or medical reasons. A low concentration in a drink can translate into a meaningful contribution to intake if the drink is a regular part of the diet. The study does not calculate actual intakes, but it supplies the concentration data needed for such calculations.

The meat alternatives are significant for a different reason. They are typically multi-ingredient products, and they are often positioned as replacements for foods that carry their own safety considerations. Testing them for mycotoxins reflects a broader effort to understand the contaminant profile of foods that are relatively new to the market.

The paper does not present the survey as representative of every country or every retail channel. Products were drawn from the UK market, and the results should be read in that context. Retail sourcing, supplier networks and formulation practices differ across countries, which means a similar survey elsewhere could produce a different pattern of detections and concentrations.

The authors also note that the category continues to change. Formulations are reformulated, suppliers are switched and new products appear regularly. A survey of this kind captures a moment in time. Repeating it periodically would show whether changes in ingredients or manufacturing practice alter the contaminant profile of the products on sale.

What mycotoxins are — and what they are not

Mycotoxins are secondary metabolites produced by certain fungi. The term covers many chemically distinct compounds, and different fungi produce different toxins under different environmental conditions. In food, the compounds of routine interest include aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, fumonisins, trichothecenes, zearalenone and patulin, among others.

A key point for consumers is that a mycotoxin detection is not the same as a mould detection. The toxin can remain in a food after the fungus that produced it has died or been removed during processing. Conversely, a food can look perfectly normal and still contain trace amounts of a toxin. This is why regulators rely on laboratory analysis rather than appearance when assessing contamination.

Nor are mycotoxins unique to plant-based foods. They are associated with conventional agricultural products such as cereals, maize, nuts, coffee and spices. Authorities including the WHO and EFSA have published extensive assessments of their occurrence and toxicity. The new survey adds a category-specific data set to that larger body of work.

The compounds can cause harm at sufficiently high exposure. Health effects described in the scientific literature include damage to the liver and kidneys, interference with immune function and an increased risk of certain cancers, depending on the toxin involved and the duration of exposure. These effects are associated with exposures substantially above the low concentrations reported in the UK survey.

The researchers are careful to state that their findings do not show that the tested products cause any of these conditions. The study was a market survey, not a clinical or epidemiological investigation. Its contribution is to describe what is present in foods people actually buy, so that later exposure modelling can put the concentrations into context.

Questions around cumulative dietary exposure

The most consequential scientific question raised by the survey is not whether a single product contains a mycotoxin, but what a whole diet delivers. Someone who uses plant-based milk in coffee each morning, eats a meat-free burger several times a week and relies on grain- and legume-based staples may encounter the same compounds from several directions.

Earlier studies cited by the researchers suggest that regular low-level consumption can contribute to cumulative exposure. The concept is familiar in food safety: regulators often assess a contaminant by estimating total intake from all relevant foods, then comparing that estimate with a health-based guidance value. A single compliant food can still matter if it is eaten often and if many other foods contribute to the same intake.

The Parma and Cranfield teams are now working on exactly that question. Their stated aim is to evaluate the risks faced by populations with different dietary habits, with particular attention to groups that rely heavily on plant-based products. That could include people following vegan or vegetarian diets, as well as those who choose these foods for reasons unrelated to ethics, such as lactose intolerance or personal preference.

The modelling work is still in progress, and the researchers have not reported exposure estimates from this survey. Until those estimates exist, the appropriate conclusion is that the detections are real, the concentrations are low, and the dietary context determines their significance.

The survey also highlights a practical difficulty. Multi-ingredient foods make exposure assessment harder because each component can introduce different contaminants. Databases used in dietary risk assessment typically record contamination at the level of raw commodities. Mapping those values onto composed products requires information about recipes and ingredient proportions that is not always available to researchers.

Known health effects at high exposure levels

Toxicological research has established that some mycotoxins can cause serious harm when exposure is high enough. Aflatoxins, for example, are associated with liver toxicity and liver cancer, particularly in combination with certain viral infections. Ochratoxin A has been studied for effects on the kidney. Fumonisins and trichothecenes have been linked to other adverse outcomes in animals and, in some settings, in humans.

These outcomes shape the guideline values that regulators use. Safety factors are applied to experimental data to derive intake levels considered protective for the general population, including more sensitive subgroups. The concentrations reported in the UK plant-based food survey were below those reference points, which is why the authors describe the food quality standards as reassuring.

That reassurance has limits. The survey measured a finite panel of 19 compounds in a finite number of products. It did not measure every possible toxin, every brand or every batch. Nor did it follow consumers to see what they actually ate. It is one piece of evidence in a larger safety picture.

The authors also stress that mycotoxins cannot be completely eliminated from the food supply. Because the fungi that produce them are widespread in the environment, absolute zero is not a realistic goal for most agricultural commodities. Food-safety systems instead aim to keep exposure as low as reasonably achievable and below levels associated with harm.

That framing is central to interpreting the headline result. The finding that every product tested contained at least one toxin is a statement about ubiquity in the ingredient supply. It is not a statement that the products are unsafe, and the researchers have consistently made that distinction in their public commentary.

Gaps in monitoring multi-ingredient foods

Regulatory attention to mycotoxins has historically focused on raw commodities and straightforward processed products such as flour, bread, peanut butter and dried fruit. Rules on maximum levels tend to be written around those categories. Plant-based meat alternatives and dairy substitutes sit in a less defined space, especially when they combine many ingredients and are marketed under names that do not map neatly onto traditional food categories.

Andrea Patriarca, a senior lecturer in mycology at Cranfield University and one of the study's authors, has pointed to the absence of established rules for monitoring mycotoxins in newly emerging foods as a particular concern. In his account, the issue is not that these products are inherently risky, but that the monitoring framework has not kept pace with the market.

The research team works with food businesses ranging from farmers to manufacturers to incorporate mycotoxin management into existing food-safety standards. Such work typically involves checking raw materials, setting supplier specifications and applying controls at points where contamination is most likely to enter the chain.

Multi-ingredient products complicate that approach. When a finished item contains components from several suppliers, a detection in the final product may be difficult to trace back to a single source. Researchers studying these foods therefore argue for better documentation of ingredient composition and more systematic testing at the raw-material stage.

The FunShield4Med project, funded under grant agreement 101079173, provides the wider framework for this line of work. Its goal is to improve the ability of food systems to anticipate fungal spoilage and mycotoxin threats, rather than simply reacting to detections after products reach the market.

The research partnership and funding

The survey is the product of a collaboration between the University of Parma and Cranfield University. Parma, in Italy, brought expertise in food chemistry and mycotoxin analysis, while Cranfield contributed mycology and experience in working with the UK food industry. The authors are based across the two institutions, and the paper lists five named researchers.

The work forms part of FunShield4Med, a project supported by the European Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under the Widening Participation and Spreading Excellence strand. The grant agreement number is 101079173. The project's stated purpose is to strengthen food safety and security by improving foresight of fungal spoilage and mycotoxin threats.

That funding context helps explain the study's design. Rather than testing a hypothesis about a specific toxin, the team set out to generate a broad data set from a product category that had not been thoroughly surveyed. Market surveys of this kind are a common first step in food-safety research because they reveal where contaminants appear and which products warrant closer attention.

The partnership is continuing with exposure work. The researchers have said they intend to evaluate risks associated with different dietary habits and to provide evidence that can inform policy decisions. They also want to raise awareness among groups they describe as potentially more vulnerable, although they have not identified those groups in detail in the published summary.

Publication in Food Control places the work in a peer-reviewed journal devoted to food-safety research. The DOI for the paper is 10.1016/j.foodcont.2025.111910, and the 2026 volume is 183.

What consumers and regulators can take away

For shoppers, the practical message is narrow. The survey found mycotoxins in all tested products, but at concentrations below EU guideline levels, and the researchers explicitly advise against fear or avoidance of a varied diet. Mycotoxins occur naturally in foods and cannot be completely removed from the supply chain.

For regulators and manufacturers, the message is more expansive. The results show that these compounds are present across a category that is growing and evolving, and that current monitoring practice may not fully reflect how these foods are made and consumed. The authors call for continued research into how different eating habits shape exposure and for food-safety systems that keep pace with new product formats.

The study also illustrates a broader shift in food-safety science. Instead of asking only whether a single food meets a limit, researchers increasingly ask how total exposure is distributed across diets and populations. Answering that question requires concentration data of the kind this survey provides, combined with consumption data and an understanding of ingredient composition.

Several uncertainties remain. The survey covered one national market at one point in time. It did not measure every toxin, and it did not estimate actual intakes. Follow-up work will need to address those gaps before any conclusion can be drawn about health effects in people who regularly consume these products.

For now, the finding stands as a description of the food environment rather than a verdict on individual products. Every item tested contained at least one fungal toxin, none exceeded the guideline benchmark used by the researchers, and the next step is to understand what that means for the diets of the people buying them.


Corrections and updates

Nexuswild welcomes factual corrections. Email contact@nexuswild.com with evidence and the article URL.